« Where Went Wednesday? | Main | Living in Interesting Times »

17 juni 2005

Let Her Die Already!

...and let him get on with his life.

I fucking hate dogmatists.

Absolutism carries the burden—no, the requirement!—of Being Right all the time. Every time. No exceptions. That's the rule.

And when you actually are Wrong, what do you do? You hedge, you change the nature of truth, and you claim Truth Once Again.

Bill Frist is on record and on tape as having watched a video of Terri Schiavo and concluding that there was no evidence that she was in a persistent vegetative state. Yesterday, after this,

An autopsy released Wednesday concluded that she had been in a persistent vegetative state and revealed no evidence that she was strangled or otherwise abused before she collapsed.

Bill Frist now says he never made any determination one way or another as to her persistent vegetative state.

He and he and they held on, held tight to the notion that she was not in a persistent vegetative state, that she clearly was alive and on the mend, and that everyone else was Wrong Wrong Wrong. All this, despite their being a martinet, an apologist and a bunch of Calvinist Catholic teens, respectively, with no evidence—much less authority—to claim truth.

They, like most of the rest of the Right Wing Machinery, came down on the side of literal life instead of quality of life. Let's call them Quantity of Life advocates, shall we? When Science failed them—as it usually does in their more strident campaigns—they turned to blame. Blame the husband. Blame his “lifestyle”. Call him names. Call him immoral. Those are easy to do, because it's all subject to interpretation, even as they call every last thing as black or white. Black or White.

Never mind that Schiavo rearranged his life to care for his wife. Never mind that he turned down $1M so that he could stay with her and make the decisions. Never mind all of that. He dared move on with his life after it was clear that his wife was gone in all but carcass. That's unforgiveable, right?

As someone who has had a partner die, as someone who never wanted to move on and yet one day, admitted defeat and finally did move on, I think I have at least some personal authority to speak on the matter. Do these people?

Regardless, they speak. And speak and speak and speak.

They were drop-dead wrong about Terri Schiavo, so what do you do when you Must Be Right And Never Wrong? Easy, you go after the husband. Ol' Jeb is investigating the husband, claiming that he waited too long before calling 911.

What total bastards!

They're going to continue to ruin this guy. Why? Because they were made fools of. Because they were wrong and they lack the humility, candor and honesty to admit that they were wrong.

You were wrong, folks. Move on. And leave that poor bastard alone.

Posted by jeff at 17 juni 2005 11:58

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:


The good news is that you might be wrong about their ability to ruin Michael Schiavo. Last time America was polled, %70 of us thought he was doing the right thing. Now that the autopsy's out, it's probably even higher in his favor.

The bad news is what's on the Fundy blogs. I actually checked, yesterday, to see what sort of shrill cries they'd be making. And sure enough, it doesn't matter what physical condition she was in. That's beside the point, they say. The point is "who are we to make that call when it's..."

wait for it...

"God's job to do that."

Terri Schiavo (TS) *would've* died without human intervention. To me, that says it all - God took her. S/he/it *wanted* TS dead. We thwarted His design for a dozen freakin' years before the vessel that once contained TS was permitted to perish. And somehow, we're still not doing his bidding? Can we win? Can we do right by this diety?

Don't answer that.

Posted by: Josh at 17 juni 2005 16:38

The good news is that apparently we can beat God. We did keep her alive YEARS after he/she/it wanted Terri gone.

Yay us! We totally beat God!

Posted by: Sam at 17 juni 2005 18:14

wow, great post

Posted by: Coffeedog at 18 juni 2005 5:49

These people never give up

Posted by: Stan at 18 juni 2005 13:12

Post a comment

Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)